Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination Tsaritsyno Kildyushov. Cool magazine

Recently, Moscow morgues are increasingly reminiscent of the private property of the head of the Moscow Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination, Yevgeny Kildyushov. Doubtful personalities are constantly rubbing near them, the registration of corpses is carried out on a paid basis, and personnel issues are resolved as if the mortuary staff were serfs of Mr. Kildyushov. How did this situation come about?

Evgeny Mikhailovich Kildyushov came to Moscow from the provinces and entered the Second Medical Institute. After graduating from this university, he was able to successfully arrange his own career by marrying a girl from a family of old Moscow doctors, one might say - the medical elite. But, having quickly climbed the career ladder and received the title of Doctor of Science, already respected and well-known in medical circles, Evgeny Mikhailovich leaves his family and unexpectedly marries again. His new chosen one was a young employee of the Department of Forensic Medicine of the Second Medical School, where by that time he was working as a leader. The young wife predictably quickly becomes an assistant professor in the same department.

But the real heyday in Kildyushov's career comes in 2012, when he takes up the post of head of the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination in Moscow. Here, Evgeny Mikhailovich clearly shows how you can quickly and easily go over the heads of others, ignoring the laws of conscience and finding loopholes for enrichment.

The Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination is engaged in hard and important work - it examines the bodies of the dead, identifies the causes of death of victims in murders, accidents and sudden deaths. The results of this work are necessary for the investigating authorities, the police, as well as heartbroken relatives, so the research must be carried out with high quality and at the appropriate professional level. The Bureau is in charge of all judicial morgues in Moscow. This is the kind of institution that Evgeny Mikhailovich manages.

Historically, each of the 11 districts of Moscow had its own branch of the bureau - the morgue, to which the bodies of the dead were delivered from all over the district. Because the Bureau of Medical Examiner's Office handles about 25,000 dead bodies each year, each county morgue had specialized funeral services in the city. But in 2010, on the territory of the Southern Administrative District, in the industrial zone at Tarny proezd, 3, a huge morgue "Tsaritsyno" was built. Gradually, the bodies of the dead began to be redistributed into it, not only in the south of the capital, but also in its other districts.

Since 2014, the funeral service at the Tsaritsyno department has been eliminated, and it has been replaced by dubious individuals who spend all their time near the reception desks and proudly call themselves Help-ritual LLC. They literally pounce on the relatives of the dead and force them to draw up funeral documents through their organization. In addition to selling ritual accessories and decorating funerals, Help Ritual also provides services for embalming the bodies of the dead, their sanitary and cosmetic treatment, although the main contingent of employees of this "office" are people who are not related to the provision of funeral services - former carriers of the dead and mortuary nurses. But the employees of the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination strongly recommend that the relatives of the victims contact them, and not the real professionals of the ritual market.

It would seem, and here Kildyushov? Everything is very simple - the bodies of the dead do not leave the territory of the Tsaritsyno morgue until they are handed over to their relatives. Maybe the funeral company employees embalm them on the mortuary grounds legally? But where, then, is the relevant lease agreement, where are the payments for the use of public premises? There are simply no payments or contracts in nature, and embalming and other services for the preparation of the deceased are performed by the Bureau's full-time orderlies, doing this during their working hours and for the state salary. The agents of "Help Ritual" can only line their pockets with money received for the work of orderlies.

But this is not enough for respected Yevgeny Mikhailovich - he decided to use his official position to provide "Help-ritual" with work at the expense of other districts of Moscow. Now the bodies of the dead from the Arbat, Taganka, Cheryomushki, East Izmailovo and Ramenok are being transported to Tsaritsyno. How much the economic component prevails over common sense and compassion for relatives, if the head of the forensic medical examination bureau ignores both the additional costs of transporting bodies to a remote morgue and the suffering of people who are forced to travel across the city to see their loved ones on their last journey.

Moreover, lately, Mr. Kildyushov has begun to think about closing those Moscow mortuaries where he fails to accommodate employees of Help-Ritual LLC. There is no other way to explain his unexpected appearances in these morgues. After hours, with a camera in hand, he looks for evidence that these morgues, which met all the necessary requirements a month ago, suddenly ceased to meet them.

Meanwhile, thanks to the “commercial” activities of Kildyushov and the increase in the load on the Tsaritsyno morgue, the quality of research and expert work there begins to suffer. With the arrival of Yevgeny Mikhailovich, the turnover of personnel has sharply increased, strong professionals survive from work by tough methods - wage cuts, rotation and the creation of impossible conditions for normal work. As a result, only in 2013 were the deputy directors forced to resign. in Economics Arbuzov R.Yu., Head of the Human Resources Department Pashovkina N.N., Head of the Supply Department Shafikov F.E., Chief Engineer Galoyan V.V., Chief Accountant Simonova V.N., Head of the Trading Department Fadeev A.S., Head of the Supply Department Chasova O.V., head of the organizational and methodological department Kochayan A.L., chief nurse Pomanskaya E.V., head of the legal department Nekrasov A.G., head of the planning and economic department Vozhzhova N.A., head of the trading department Ponomareva M. AT. and many other doctors and laboratory assistants.

Why was it necessary to get rid of employees who know their work well and are devoted to it? The answer is simple - all those who could prevent the Bureau from turning into a personal feeder of a resourceful official were left behind.

However, the closure of a number of morgues and personnel losses may also have a prolonged negative effect associated with the training of medical students in clinical departments. Future doctors have lost the opportunity to study their profession in full and improve practical skills during training. What is the future of our healthcare with this approach?

But let's leave aside the issues related to the mechanism of seizure of the funeral services market of the city of Moscow by a state institution, and briefly dwell on another banal fact - embezzlement from the state treasury. Their scheme is primitive - overstating the initial prices of auctions, guaranteed victory of "their" firms in competitions, acknowledgment of outstanding work as completed in full.

Examples are auctions for the supply of anti-plague suits, in which the initial price was at least twice as high, and the budget losses amounted to hundreds of thousands of rubles. Ensuring victories in tenders of the companies Alarm-911 LLC, Sfera LLC, related to Kildyushov's deputy for economic work Doronina O.A. Signing of acts of performance of work on the creation of a single computer network between the departments of the bureau, although such a network has not yet been created. And this is not all cases.

But one-time enrichment from the state treasury does not suit Kildyushov, who decides, using his position and position, to become an unofficial businessman. The head of the bureau turns his attention to the sphere of funeral services, since he already has considerable experience in this area, and Help-Ritual LLC is rapidly developing under his patronage.

What lies ahead for us? The concentration of 25,000 bodies of the dead in the Tsaritsyno morgue? Transport collapse in the industrial zone in Tarny proezd, where is it located? A mockery of heartbroken people standing in huge lines for the bodies of their loved ones? Endless trips of police officers to obtain the necessary documents instead of working to protect citizens? What quality of expertise can we talk about if the experts have to work in two shifts?

It is clear that Help-ritual LLC is just a tool for making money, a gasket that allows Kildyushov to solve his personal financial issues, and, taking advantage of his official position, use his employees for this. But how to find out whether the whole system is rotting or just specific people in it? Yevgeny Mikhailovich, will you answer or those who are behind you?

P.S. While the material for this article was being collected, by the sole decision of Mr. Kildyushov, another department was closed - morgue No. 2, the work of which will now be carried out by the Tsaritsyno department. Which branch is next?

Corsicans or Sicilians are considered to be recognized experts in bloody types of revenge - but the RP columnist Alexander Rokhlin finds irrefutable, medically confirmed evidence that bloodiness is not entirely alien to our compatriots.

What was it?

Tragifarce or devilish joke? The boundaries of meaning are blurred, like the features of a drowned man. Acting is a dubious pleasure. And I, obviously, watched the theater. It's written on the building. And stone letters. The founders were sure that nothing else would ever appear here. So I saw the play. The action unfolded, it must be admitted, rotten. But very convincing. Yes Yes! Exceptional authenticity combined with incredible lifelessness. How to explain? Very simple.

The actors were… dead. All as one. The identities of some were impossible to recognize at all, since only fragments of their mortal bodies took part in the drama. You can’t relax here: you are the only living participant in what is happening. As a spectator of what is happening ... You quickly understand how easily what is happening could become your sad outgoing. Not a single actor in this theater died a natural death, but exclusively by force. Actually, the whole performance is based on the fact of the death of the performer. Details and nuances. Death at the hands of a neighbor, as a result of accidents, revenge, malicious intent, laying on of hands, blows with blunt objects, piercing and cutting objects, poisonous substances and other methods of exclusion from the book of the living.

So, it wasn't a morgue. But the anatomical theater. Department of Forensic Medicine of the Research University. N.I. Pirogov.

A magnificent building, where vaults, arches, auditorium doors, semi-dark corridors, flickering lamps on the walls, flights of stairs with marble steps and wrought iron railings - everything is solemn, heavy and saturated with bitter experience. Temple of Science. The only temple where theater is appropriate. The only theater that serves science, not entertainment. A person must feel at ease here. Here the causes of his death, the conclusions of posthumous examinations are higher and more important than all his aspirations, passions, mistakes and victories in life.

“... After that, the condemned to death was subjected to scourging. For this purpose, they took off his clothes and tied him by the hands to a pole in the territory of the court. Then he was flogged with a short whip called flagrum (or flagellum). The whip consisted of a hilt, to which leather straps of various lengths were attached, with pieces of lead woven into the ends, and jagged fragments of bones along the length ...

Flagrum blows were applied by one or two executors of punishments (lictors) on the back, buttocks and thighs of the convict. They only avoided striking the projection of the heart, because this could lead to premature death. The consequences of such scourging were truly terrifying. In places where the flagrum straps hit, the skin was torn, and the underlying soft tissues were crushed. It is no coincidence that the whip for punishment was sometimes also called flagrum taxillatum - a stinging whip, “a terrifying scourge”.

At the same time, flagellation, causing extensive damage to the soft tissues of the back, could not lead to significant blood loss, since it did not damage any large blood vessels. Bleeding from the blood vessels of the skin and subcutaneous fat damaged during the execution was relatively insignificant and stopped soon enough ... "

The building of the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination of the Moscow Health Department is regularly visited by citizens. At the entrance they are met by security, willingly answering questions of a reference nature. And it is here, in front of the metal turntable at the entrance-exit, that citizens and visitors find themselves in an awkward position. Very characteristic...

They ask the guards: “How to pass the examination?” And the guards patiently ask again: “What kind of examination do you want - dead or alive?” A simple question, but all the visitors are embarrassed, make surprised eyes, not knowing what to answer, and giggle stupidly. Man is never ready. Neither judgment nor death. But it is in these two areas that forensic medicine reigns supreme. Producing the word "judicial" not from the court, but from fate.

There is also a museum here. My tongue will no longer turn to call this assembly of horror and gloom the house of the Muses. In the latter, you can at least laugh at mothballs. Exhibits living in the world of forensics only cause convulsions. And convulsive grimaces. Question one. How was the damage done? Killed? How? And for what period of time? And here are the answers: knives, knives, sharpeners, blades, rods, awls, screwdrivers, saws, chisels. And the handles are carved, type-setting, mother-of-pearl ...

No… It's not about that. Here, in the closet, lives an old woman! The convulsions begin. Mom dear! Just think about it ... The old woman lives in a closet - a figure of speech. Because the “old woman” is a corpse, one hundred percent, beyond doubt, but in such a degree of preservation that if you don’t know ... Like a living one! She lives, in the sense of staying, causing a strong emotional reaction when meeting. Not for the faint hearted and impressionable. Skin, hair, bones, internal organs - everything is natural, our own. There is a hole in the eyes, a grin in the teeth, but a golden ring on the finger. Grimace of death; twisted life. This death has been in the museum cabinet since 1963. And before that, for another twenty years, she “lived” on the mezzanine in a Moscow apartment, in the Meshchanskaya Sloboda. The forensic examination in a laconic certificate tells that citizen N. lived in her natural form and was in good health until she died in 1942. And her own sister, who occupied a common living space with her, decided to temporarily hide the fact of death in order to use food cards for two. And she concealed it... The amazing thing is that the deceased in the most incredible way escaped rotting. Science is not able to explain and only states. The old woman from Meshchanskaya just dried up like an autumn leaf. Strictly speaking, mummified. Without outside help. Remember Lenin! How much effort and money he requires from his descendants, but here everything is for nothing ...

After some time, the greedy sister removed the corpse on the mezzanine and ... forgot about it. It turned out to be easy: with a height of 150 cm, the weight of the mummy sister is only 4 kg 100 grams. Thus, this "living" corpse continues to exist. And work on the history of forensic medicine. As a monument to the wonders of human cruelty and stupidity.

An extract from a forensic medical examination, which ... was not

“In order for the crucified person to remain alive on the cross for as long as possible and thus prolong the agony of the victim, the Romans used various devices that provided some support for the body of the victim (this may explain the phrase “sitting on the cross” used by the Romans). For this purpose, a small ledge, or seat (sedile), was sometimes used, which was placed on the staticulum in such a way that this seat passed between the legs of the condemned. To increase the suffering of the victim, the seat was sometimes made pointed. Instead of the seat, sometimes they made an emphasis on the legs in the form of a plank nailed to the bottom of the staticulum (pedale, or suppedaneum), which was less painful than being on a pointed seat, but also prolonged the suffering of the convict. In both cases, the crucified person, rather, did not hang on the cross, but sat or stood, nailed to it ...

After conducting a series of experiments with amputated hands, as well as with corpses, P. Barbet discovered facts that were unexpected at that time. It turned out that when nailed to the cross at the level of the middle of the palms, the brushes fell off the nails with a load of about 39 kg (88 pounds). Experimental data confirmed mathematical calculations that showed that in the position on the cross, during which the hands of the crucified depart from the body to the patibulum at an angle close to 68 °, the body of the condemned will certainly fall off the cross.

Looking for an anatomical place that could, on the one hand, fully correspond to the Gospel text and historical chronicles, and on the other hand, securely hold the weight of the crucified on the nails, P. Barbet came to the conclusion that the Desto space on the wrist is best suited for this. (Destot) .

If the nail was driven into the space of Desto located between the triangular, capitate and hamate bones of the wrist, the hands of the crucified were securely held on the cross, regardless of his body weight. An important circumstance was also the fact that when the nails passed through Desto's space, the bleeding from the pierced wrists is relatively insignificant, since there is no damage to the large main blood vessels.

Evgeny Mikhailovich Kildyushov knows about revenge more than other people. Did he take revenge? Revenge him? Let's leave behind the scenes ... He heads the Bureau of Forensic Medicine and the Department of the same medicine at Pirogov University. He is a doctor, expert and boss. A very balanced person. An exceptionally knowledgeable person. From him I will hear:

“Revenge is war. And war is death. Forensic medicine knows more about it than others ... "

A copy of the portrait of the Russian doctor Minakov hangs in his office. One of the founding fathers of the department. Take a close look. The doctor - very similar to Chekhov - sits in deep thought ... Of course! In his hands is a human skull. Why did he die? Was there any violence? How to prove?

“The medical examiner knows everything. But it's too late."

Dr. Kildyushov's remark.

Too late for the deceased or deceased. Who personally doesn't care. But it's never too late for history. Which is eternal. This is the uniqueness of science. Recall the first trial in which the judgment of a medical expert resulted in a guilty verdict. The case of Madame Lafargue, accused of poisoning her husband in 1840.

Remember the English king Charles II, who dabbled in alchemy and experiments with mercury ... He died in the seventeenth century, the reasons became clear in the twentieth. Remember the sworn "friend" of our Napoleon Bonaparte, whose death from arsenic chemists confirmed 150 years later. And do not forget that unfortunate man, whose head in the portrait is held in the hands of Dr. Minakov. He died from a blow ... a bear paw. And his skull, a century later, keeps traces of the last meeting.

“Forensic medicine does not judge. She only knows the truth...

This is her second exceptional quality. Don't judge. Hence such a balance in the reasoning of Evgeny Mikhailovich. He doesn't say any extra words. It's like they're not in his vocabulary.

“Forensic medicine understands the frailty of life better than others ... Man is an extremely resistant and at the same time fragile creature.” And the best confirmation of the words of the chief forensic expert in Moscow is the unique university collection of mortal, fragile, persistent and somewhere even non-existent (that is, beyond good and evil) human material.

From here begins the very theater where there is no smell of acting, there is no smell at all. Here you feel a strange emptiness, by no means mysterious, but attractive. So it attracts a flight of stairs from a height of the tenth floor. It seems that demons flit in flocks behind your back. Suddenly you remember: “Revenge is the daughter of stupidity. You can ignore both, if not for the deadly consequences "...

And then in front of the glass showcases with "mortal exhibits" knees become unpleasantly cold.

An extract from a forensic medical examination, which ... was not

“In order to shorten the time of torment of those crucified on the cross, there was a custom of crurifragium (skelokopia), which was used in cases where, for some reason, a decision was made to hasten the death of the condemned.

In the course of skelecopy, the bones of the legs were broken with a crucified hammer, after which the body of the convict lost its point of support and hung on his hands. Under these conditions, overextension of the chest quickly set in and suffocation came much faster - within several tens of minutes and even faster.

This point has been convincingly proven by K-S.D. Schulte, who, in a series of controlled experiments on volunteers, showed that if the crucifixion occurred only due to hanging on the hands, without relying on the legs, then in all subjects, already at the 6th minute, the volume of inhaled air decreased by approximately 70%, blood pressure fell by 50% of the norm, and the heart rate doubled. After 12 minutes, breathing was carried out only due to the movements of the diaphragm and loss of consciousness occurred.

When the volunteers were allowed to periodically (once within 20 seconds) lean on their feet during crucifixion, there was a pronounced normalization of the activity of the cardiovascular system and respiration. The experiment in the latter case lasted up to 30-40 minutes, after which the subjects experienced severe pain in the wrists and the experiment was terminated at this point.

P. Barbet's theory that the death of those condemned to crucifixion occurred as a result of positional asphyxia due to the position of the body of the crucified on the cross, seems quite convincing, reasonably explaining the onset of death in crucified people, and is currently accepted by almost all researchers.

However, paying tribute to the pioneering works of P. Barbet, it should still be recognized that, having revealed the features of the onset of death during crucifixion, he could not adequately explain one specific case - the death of Jesus Christ on the cross.

I saw a collection of stomachs poisoned with sulfuric, carbolic, nitric acids, caustic, sublimate, formalin. A breathtaking sight!

Dummies, but made of real human material. That is, these were the stomachs that belonged to people who had the misfortune to get poisoned or be poisoned. The color scheme was amazing. Green, crimson, yellow, purple and brown stomachs stared at me from behind the panes.

Following the stomachs, in the same variety of colors, were poisoned esophaguses, intestines, ruined lungs, torn hearts and livers, abscessed brains, crushed faces, fingers, severed heads and other parts of people marked by violence. Each of them was "voiced" by a blatant monologue - a short note (an elegant curlicue) characterizing the case. As if they were greeting cards, and not posthumous conclusions of examinations. I read them, and the hair should have moved on my head ...

"The skin of the face during self-poisoning with caustic alkali."

"Spontaneous rupture of the heart."

"Forehead breaks".

"Compression of a block of earth."

"Fatal wounds from an accidental fall on a knife (butcher, aged 62)."

"Boots of Lieutenant Petrov with traces of being crushed by a passenger train on October 25, 1947."

“Citizen S., who for a long time suffered from osteomyelitis of the bones in the region of the left wrist joint, cut off his 5th finger with an ax first at the level of the middle part of the metacarpal bone, and then the hand at the level of the wrist joint ...”

And simply: the hands and head of a Papuan, the hands of a farmer, a cook, a shoemaker, a cutter.

And a completely transcendent exhibit - the face of a dead man with a sign: “The formation of a fat wax. Staying in a coffin for 54 years ... "

The topic of our lecture today is positional asphyxia. It must be admitted that of all the types of asphyxia that we know ... By the way, how much?

The interns were silent, and the lecturer quickly listed them from memory ...

So, of all the types of asphyxia in the Soviet Union, one type has never been studied, being under a ban ... And this is positional asphyxia. “Oblivion” is connected with the fact that the most famous case of positional asphyxia in history immediately led us to whom? That's right, - continued the associate professor, although none of the students opened their mouths, - to the crucifixion of Jesus Christ. It was somehow not convenient for an atheistic state to delve into the details of the death of the Lord God ...

The docent smiled. But the interns did not move, they did not understand the joke.

And why? - Associate Professor Tumanov asked with a sad smile. - But because the conclusions of the science of death fit too easily into the text of the Gospel ...

Tumanov paused. I took a breath and no longer remember how I breathed. Because it was the most incredible and merciless preaching of Christianity that I have ever heard in my life. Incredible, because the science of death knows no sentiment. Merciless, because it left no doubts.

What Kildyushov spoke sparingly and briefly about - for forensic medicine there is no prescription of time - I felt on my own skin. Tumanov gave a lecture as if he himself were conducting an examination of the body of Jesus Christ. And we were present.

Grimaces of death grinned at us from behind glass cabinets, but the intoxicating emptiness disappeared, was erased, as a stupid anecdote is erased from memory.

Kildyushov said that forensic medicine does not judge anyone, but knows the truth.

The more valuable this only truth ...

What did Jesus Christ die from?

And what does domestic forensic medicine say about this?

An extract from a forensic medical examination, which ... was not

“Summarizing the above, it can be reasonably assumed that the death of Jesus Christ occurred as a result of the development of DIC. Most likely in the hypercoagulable phase...

DIC is an acquired pathology of the blood coagulation system, which is characterized by circulatory disorders at the level of the microvasculature in vital organs (liver, kidneys, adrenal glands, lungs, etc.). Developing in many cases of acute conditions, including injuries, DIC can occur within a few hours and cause extremely high mortality in victims ...

The circumstances that caused the development of this pathological condition were scourging with extensive damage to the soft tissues of the back and their further traumatization, which occurred both during the carrying of the cross and during the stay on it during the crucifixion. Additional conditions that determined the development of DIC were increasing hypoxia due to shortness of breath, increasing hypovolemia as a result of blood loss and dehydration, unnatural position of the body on the cross, pain flow from extremities pierced by nails and strong psycho-emotional shock.

“... And he who saw testified, and his testimony is true; he knows that he speaks the truth so that you may believe” (John 19:34-35).

The note uses excerpts from an article by Associate Professor E.V. Tumanov "Death at the crucifixion. View of a forensic expert.

The largest state mortuary in Moscow was turned into a private commercial enterprise

The Russian funeral service traditionally prefers peace and quiet. But under their mourning veil sometimes such gloomy secrets are hidden that one can only be amazed. One of these stories is closely connected with the head of the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination of the city of Moscow, Yevgeny Kildyushov, who managed to turn the largest state mortuary into a personal commercial enterprise. Having subjugated several "ritual" firms and concentrating the expertise of the Moscow dead in one place, Mr. Kildyushov became, in fact, the uncrowned king of this coffin business.

Some time ago, Europe's largest forensic morgue "Tsaritsyno" was built in Moscow, to which the bodies of the dead are delivered from all over the city.

The Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination, headed by Kildyushov, is located in the same building. As other Moscow mortuaries close, Tsaritsyno takes over their load.

Despite the heavy workload of the morgue, in 2014 the funeral service was liquidated in it, and merchants from Angel LLC took over its functions. As a result, at least a strange situation has developed - forensic experts send relatives of the dead to this company, it collects money from them, and the preparation of corpses for burial, embalming and other services are performed by the orderlies of the city morgue, during their working hours and for the budgetary salary. As a result, it is the “Angel” that now really and legally takes all the turnover from ritual activities.

Not surprisingly, most professionals who have worked in this system for decades have chosen to quit. Soon there was no one left in Tsaritsyno who could prevent the transformation of the morgue into a source of enrichment for the cunning head of the bureau.

Another dubious "business" of the expert bureau and its leader is the removal of internal organs from corpses. According to Russian law, this is permissible if the person did not prohibit such actions during his lifetime. But as cynical as it sounds, everything has a price, and human organs have a very specific value. Through what channels the organs confiscated in Tsaritsyno go, where and for what money - remains a mystery behind seven seals, carefully guarded by Mr. Kildyushov and his "colleagues".

In August 2014, this story received a new continuation. The Moscow Department of Health issued an order to redistribute the districts of Moscow into departments of the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination - "in order to further improve the organization of forensic medical examination, rational and efficient use of healthcare resources." According to this order, the next forensic morgue is being closed and all corpses will now be sent to the Tsaritsyno morgue.

We are talking about morgue No. 16, opened due to numerous requests from the population of New Moscow. At first, corpses from the new territories attached to the capital were sent to the Tsaritsyno morgue, which was extremely inconvenient due to the remoteness, since each deceased has relatives, including the elderly, who want to see a loved one on their last journey. But, according to the decision of the Department, in September the judicial morgue No. 16 will cease to exist as an independent institution and will move to Tarny proezd, to the Tsaritsyno morgue.

This is not the first reduction in the number of Moscow morgues. In the spring of this year, morgue No. 2, which was a kind of brand of Russian doctors, was closed. Entire generations of doctors from all over the country have studied forensic medicine here! Yes, and Mr. Kildyushov himself owes his career to this morgue!

Morgues are closed under various formal pretexts, under which, by the way, any morgue can be closed, and first of all - the notorious Tsaritsyno. However, it is quite obvious that only those branches are subject to closure, in which the interests of funeral organizations friendly to Mr. Kildyushov are not represented. This, alas, is a fact.

It is worth noting that, unlike the now closed morgues No. 2 and No. 16, in Tsaritsyno and some other divisions of the Bureau, by the efforts of Kildyushov himself and with the active participation of the Deputy for Economic Affairs, the former official of the Ministry of Health Doronina O.A. extra-budgetary activities have been organized to prepare the bodies of the dead for release, which is implemented through private ritual organizations. At the same time, Kildyushov himself actively positions himself as having nothing to do with ritual services. Maybe. But then the question arises why Kildyushov acts contrary to common sense, the interests of the Bureau, destroying its infrastructure, and also contrary to the interests of ordinary people who are forced to go to the ends of the earth to bury their relatives, just like that, "for the love of art"? Or maybe this is proof that the actual head of the Bureau is Doronina, which has long been said and written about? Well, we must give her credit - she deftly pulls her puppet by the strings!

Morgue No. 15, located in the city of Troitsk, was appointed the next candidate for closure. After that, all of New Moscow will be forced to go to the Tsaritsino morgue, located in an industrial area, far from transport interchanges. So greed wins over common sense!

It is necessary to say a few words about the work of the Tsaritsyno complex itself. In addition to the already described extrabudgetary activities of the head of the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examinations, there are other problems there. For example, among the employees of the morgue, tuberculosis flourishes as an occupational disease, caused by a huge number of incoming corpses, including those with a verified diagnosis of tuberculosis and HIV infection.

In one sectional hall of Tsaritsyno, about 20 corpses can be opened in one working day. Often, employees spend there for five hours a day, while, despite the absence of any instructions in the regulatory documents, in the dissection room, the forensic medical examiner must completely write the Act of the forensic medical examination of the corpse, which also applies to people who died from tuberculosis and HIV infections.

The corpses coming from specialized hospitals, in order to comply with the formalities and the legality of their stay in the morgue, come to Tsaritsyno as the bodies of unknown persons, although photocopies of the passports of the dead are found in the case histories. In addition, the Tsaritsyno morgue receives putrefied corpses from almost the entire territory of Moscow. It should also not be forgotten that there is also a corpse storage facility on the territory of the Tsaritsyno complex. In all likelihood, the “rational and efficient use of healthcare resources” is to create a kind of “city of the dead” on the territory of Moscow, which is a constant hotbed of various infections and socially significant diseases.

Such responsible and unhealthy work should be appropriately paid. By order of the DZM, a point-based remuneration system, which looks like some kind of fraudulent scheme, was introduced into the practice of the Bureau in an emergency mode. From January of this year to the present, this system has already changed five times, as a result, the cost of a point has decreased from 1000 to 250 rubles. How the cost of one point is calculated today, how money is distributed among branches and how they are accrued to specific individuals, is unknown. It is not possible to obtain any clarification from the management of the Bureau of the JME. The Bureau has completely stopped substitution payments for sick leaves and vacations, which is a violation of labor laws. Thus, there is a decrease in the wages of ordinary employees.

The Bureau of SMEs in Moscow has a long history and has always been distinguished by the high quality of expertise that completely satisfied the customer. With the arrival of Yevgeny Kildyushov to the leadership of the bureau, the quality of the examinations suddenly ceased to suit the administration. Numerous spontaneous unscheduled checks began in the institution, introducing dissonance into the work of the departments. Very often the requirements of one inspector contradict the requirements of another. The quality control of examinations, carried out by the administration of the Bureau, mainly comes down to checking the number of commas, paragraphs and font size, which does not affect the true quality of examinations and the "conclusions" of experts. All complaints about the quality of examinations are made orally, are not regulated in any way, in places they contradict the Code of Criminal Procedure, and therefore their elimination is impossible and leads to sabotage of the work of the institution.

At the same time, often unreasonable disciplinary sanctions are announced to employees for the slightest fault, entailing the abolition of bonuses and incentive payments. By now, most of the Bureau's employees are already under one form or another of disciplinary sanctions, which probably contributes to an increase in the wage savings fund, from which Kildyushov himself and his entourage receive bonuses incomparable with the salaries of ordinary employees.

The apogee of this situation was the verification of expert activities in the form of debossing corpses in order to reweigh the organs and re-measure their sizes, without drawing up and providing any documents. The inspectors cannot answer the question about the legal aspects of these actions. But what about the dignified treatment of the body of the deceased, regulated by the Funeral Act?

I must say that this kind of frequent checks, and even more so the invention of various ridiculous, interfering with normal work, and often simply illiterate requirements, testifies to the low professional level of their initiators. Yes, this is not surprising - a typical native of the scientific community, who did not open a single more or less serious case on his own, Kildyushov, despite his professorship, has no idea about the real goals, objectives and methods of practical forensic medicine. This is also evidenced by the appointment to the most responsible positions in the bureau of people who are not known to anyone, who do not enjoy authority among employees, but who are clearly promoted by someone. At the same time, the principle of recruitment is not the candidate's professionalism, but his "loyalty", by which Kildyushov means full support of his policy aimed at the collapse of the Bureau's infrastructure and denunciation of his fellow workers for any reason.

It is quite obvious that the activities of the head of the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination lead to the inevitable destruction of the system created by generations of Moscow forensic experts, the further loss of the authority of Moscow forensic medicine among law enforcement officers and colleagues - doctors of other specialties. And all this is happening against the backdrop of complete indifference of the parent organization - the capital's Department of Health. While officials are inactive, experts and orderlies, at the suggestion of Kildyushov, are forced to become undertakers.

After the release of this article, most likely, the employees of the Bureau of SME will be subjected to even greater repression and harassment by the administration, and possibly dismissal, so the phrase suggests itself - all characters are fictional, all coincidences are random. Hold on, Bureau staff!

See the original material on the site "Top Secret":

Last week, the FSB searched the main morgue in Moscow - Tsaritsynsky. And immediately, its director Evgeny Kildyushov, together with the deputy Oksana Doronina, wrote statements on their own. Now the Investigative Committee has begun a pre-investigation check at the request of the morgue employees, which may end with a criminal case for the former heads. Accountants and pathologists told investigators about the gray financial schemes of their leadership. They allegedly paid wages to dead souls and purchased equipment at an inflated price.

Mortuary in question

The Tsaritsyno morgue is an informal name. Officially it is called the Bureau of Forensic Medicine. It is located in the industrial zone, in Tarny passage. The huge building with a green roof is considered the largest forensic morgue in Europe. Corpses with criminal causes of death are brought there from all over Moscow. Since 2004, 50-year-old Evgeny Kildyushov has been invariably in charge of it. At the same time, he served as the chief freelance forensic specialist in Moscow. Around 2013, he appointed Oksana Doronina, hereditary physician, to the post of his deputy. And last Thursday, both quit, writing a statement of their own free will.

There were reasons for this. Since 2015, more and more claims have been raised against the mortuary regarding the quality of work, working conditions, and even criminal claims. At some point, a critical mass of them accumulated, and FSB operatives came with searches to the building at Tarny, 3.

At the disposal of the publication were documents signed by the deputy head of the department of the capital's FSB, which indicate that the Chekists became interested in the morgue at least as early as August 2017.

It is known about at least three pre-investigation checks that were carried out in relation to the morgue through the TFR. The first began after a collective statement by a dozen employees of the morgue: accountants, orderlies, pathologists. According to the first, the management paid salaries to dead souls - people who are only on paper listed at work in the morgue.

Employees also talk about the fact that the authorities allegedly purchased equipment for the morgue at an inflated cost. The papers say that some of the equipment was allegedly purchased through firms controlled by the deputy director Doronina.

Inventory and medicines are purchased at significantly inflated prices through firms controlled by Kildyushov E.M. and Doronina O.A., from budgetary funds, - it is said in the documents sent to the UK.

According to the Kartoteka.ru database, five Moscow firms were registered for Doronina's full namesake at different times. One of them - Torusmed LLC - really entered into state contracts with the morgue. True, they were not devoted to the supply of goods, but to the maintenance of equipment.

From 2013 to 2015, Torusmed repaired and maintained refrigeration systems in the morgue. Over the years, the morgue paid her 6.9 million rubles. All contracts from the side of the JME Bureau were signed by Oksana Doronina. Other firms of Doronin's mortuary did not sell anything, at least through government contracts.

According to Pavel Zaitsev, a former investigator for especially important cases, a member of the National Anti-Corruption Committee, this story has the potential for a criminal case.

There is no conflict of interest here, because the deputy director of the bureau can formally dispose of other companies. However, if the investigation proves that the prices for goods or services were inflated, we can talk about initiating a case on embezzlement of budget funds on government contracts, Zaitsev told Life.

The second pre-investigation check began after Life's publication last year that organs of the dead were illegally removed in the Tsaritsyno morgue. The investigator then issued a decision to refuse to initiate a case, but a month later the prosecutor's office canceled it and sent the materials for a new consideration.

Only the third check, initiated at the request of the mortuary forensic experts, ended in a criminal case.

contagious affair

According to a source familiar with the investigation, Yevgeny Kildyushov was recently interviewed in a negligence case filed over a year ago. First, he was investigated in the Nagatinsk district administration, and then taken to the district - SU in the South Administrative District. But so far there are no accused in the case. Although there are results of checks by Rospotrebnadzor and a decision of the civil court. They directly write: “Conditions have been created in the morgue under which employees can become infected with dangerous infections.”

Back in 2015, two female pathologists wrote a complaint against Kildyushov about negligence. They contracted tuberculosis during autopsy. The victims believed that this happened because they were not given respirators and were not provided with sanitation of the premises, and the ventilation was not repaired. The most common way of infection with tuberculosis is airborne, and when the pathologists open the lungs, the pathogen is in the air. And in the sectional hall, they just did not install normal ventilation.

According to various sources, about 13 employees, including male orderlies, became infected. But only two girls filed a complaint with the police.

Since then, Rospotrebnadzor commissions have come to the morgue every year. Over and over again they wrote in their examinations: the morgue does not repair ventilation, does not renovate offices and spits on the sanitary condition of its own buildings. Such an approach of management can lead to dangerous consequences for personnel, sums up consumer supervision. The former head of the morgue Yevgeny Kildyushov was also recognized as the person responsible for the violations.

The last check of Rospotrebnadzor on this matter took place in November 2016. They issued an order: to complete repairs in the offices, the sectional hall of the morgue, in the basement and the dining room, - a source familiar with the situation tells Life. - The deadline was set until the end of April 2017.

However, when in April the inspectors again came to the Bureau of the SME, it turned out that the order had not been fulfilled, and the repair had not been completed. Then the inspectors went to court to sue the morgue for deliberate failure to comply with the instructions. In August, the justice of the peace of the Tsaritsyno district granted the claim of Rospotrebnadzor and forced the mortuary to pay a fine of 10,000 under Article 19.5 of the Code of Administrative Offenses. The court ruling stated that it was the lack of repair that contributed to the spread of dangerous infections like tuberculosis.

However, Maria Vyalshina, investigator of the Investigative Department from the Southern District, is apparently not particularly impressed by these arguments. She has not been able to find the suspects for 13 months, and only in July appointed the first examination. This happened only after the injured forensic expert visited a personal appointment with the deputy head of the Moscow investigation, Colonel Sergei Yarosh. It is noteworthy that Yarosh was suspended from work last week due to the delay in the investigation of another criminal case.

Meanwhile, important evidence is missing from the case. According to the injured forensic expert, a chest X-ray and a medical record have disappeared from the materials, confirming that the woman really had tuberculosis.

premium post

Claims to the morgue arose not only from Rospotrebnadzor. The Prosecutor General's Office and Rostrud more than once sent troops of inspectors to Tarny Proyezd in 2016–2017. The checks carried out on behalf of the Prosecutor General's Office were unsuccessful. But Rostrud found serious jambs. The chief accountant of the bureau, Irina Mezentseva, was fined for not paying cashiers for months of part-time work. The bureau, as a legal entity, was also fined 30,000 because of this.

But the bosses did not spare money for bonuses and allowances. So, Life has copies of the payrolls of the morgue: Kildyushov's salary in the best months was 621 thousand rubles, and his deputies - 200-400 thousand. Most of them consist of bonuses and additional payments.

Last Friday, the staff of the morgue was introduced to a new boss - it turned out to be Ekaterina Koludarova. Previously, she was the head of the histology department at the same mortuary. The appointment took place literally in the presence of investigators - they were just confiscating papers.

The "godfather" of the funeral business holds the whole of Moscow in his fist

Andrey Petrov